Neighboring New Jersey, Massachusetts, and New York face the highest health insurance premiums
Take Command analysis of U.S. Department of Health & Human Services data | Image Credit: Take Command
Health insurance premiums vary widely across the U.S., with the highest costs concentrated in Northeastern states. New Jersey, Massachusetts, and New York report the highest average premiums for both single and family coverage. In 2023, the average premium for single coverage in New Jersey reached $9,662, while family coverage in the state cost an average of $26,870—both well above the national averages of $8,182 for single and $23,938 for family coverage. Neighboring states Massachusetts and New York follow closely behind, with family coverage premiums averaging $26,355 in each.
High premiums in the Northeast reflect the region’s high per capita healthcare spending, which according to the U.S. Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services is about . Additionally, states in this region often have more comprehensive healthcare mandates and regulations, which can result in .
In contrast, states in the South and parts of the Midwest report some of the lowest average premiums. For instance, in Mississippi, the average premium was $7,243 for single coverage and $21,939 for family coverage in 2023. These lower premiums may reflect lower healthcare spending per capita, less comprehensive plans offered by employers, and fewer mandates that affect plan coverage requirements.
For businesses looking to mitigate the cost of rapidly rising employer-sponsored health insurance premiums, there are a few options to consider. Partnering with a Professional Employer Organization (PEO) allows small and medium-sized businesses to co-employ their staff, granting access to the  with more competitive rates and administrative support. Alternatively, Association Health Plans (AHPs) enable small businesses to band together and leverage their collective purchasing power for better rates and coverage. For an affordable, tax-advantaged solution, Health Reimbursement Arrangements () allow employers to reimburse employees for individual insurance premiums and medical expenses on a pre-tax basis, offering flexibility and significant savings. These strategies help businesses manage costs while providing individualized health benefit options.
Below is a breakdown of health insurance premiums by state and metropolitan area. The analysis was conducted by —a platform that helps companies provide health benefits to employees through Health Reimbursement Arrangements—using data from the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services. For more information, see  on Take Command.